Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
January 18, 2018 at 8:16 pm in reply to: Your most practical lens for event photography AND portraits #28444
Matthew StevensParticipant+1 for what James said… For all purpose shooting where I don’t know exactly what I’m going to encounter, for a full frame I mostly leave my f/4 24-120mm on the camera (with a DX body the same went for my 16-85mm, which was the same effective focal range). For event shooting where I typically can’t get too close to the subjects, or I want to isolate a particular subject (an expression on someones face for instance), I like the f/4 70-200. For portraits, where I have time to frame my subjects, it’s hard to beat the f/1.8 85mm.
Matthew StevensParticipantI would be a bit careful about using ken rockwell as a source.. from his About page: “This website is a work of fiction, entirely the product of my own imagination and personal opinion.”
He does have some true stuff on there, but picking the truth out of the “entertainment” as he calls it can be more trouble than it is worth (and I say that from experience 🙂
That said, David has got it right about the differences between the two cameras. The autofocus is nice on the D5xxx series vs the D3xxx (I used to have a D5200). Here’s a side by side comparison of the features on both cameras that might be handy. http://www.imaging-resource.com/cameras/nikon/d5300/vs/nikon/d3400/
You can’t really go wrong starting out with either one, although personally I’d spring for the D5300 for the better autofocus alone.
Matthew StevensParticipantThere’s a couple reasons a sports photographer (which I’d assume the adorama guy was) to choose the D500 over the 750. One is buffer capacity (basically the super fast memory built into the camera, where it stores the data off the sensor momentarily before writing it to the much slower SD card) is larger on the D500. That’s why it can shoot 10fps vs the 6.5 in the 750. Is that important for you? I’m not sure. only you an really answer that. However, I’ve shot with the 7100 and 750, and have never really found it necessary to shoot at 10fps. I am not a sports photographer, and don’t need to freeze action of someone hitting a baseball or making a tackle or whatever. I have shot quite a bit of kids running around like at the ATI conferences, some guys at Nantahala river in kayaks who were doing trick and stuff like that. For kids, 6fps has always been plenty. For the kayakers, I did need it a bit faster. However, I was outside in a well lit area, and figured I wouldn’t need to do much post processing on the images. So I switched the camera to shoot in jpeg, which are smaller files and can shoot faster (since the buffer is big enough to hold many more jpg than raw). That was plenty fast enough for that situation.
The other reason a lot of the same people who want high frame rates tend to like DX sensors is the crop factor. It means they can get more “reach” out of the same lens. The adorama guy’s 200mm lens is the equivalent to a 300mm lens on a full frame camera. So, it’s better suited for shooting fast, far away subjects like at a football game.
You *can* shoot at 6400 iso on a crop sensor. And you can make it look ok with some post processing. Personally, I never really went over 3200 most times on my 7100, because I wasn’t happy with the image quality. DX sensors just get grainy at high iso, no getting around it. Because the light receptors on the sensor are smaller than a full frame, the only way to make up for it when shooting in the dark is to boost the iso, essentially taking whatever light is hitting the sensor and amplifying it. If you’ve ever turned the speakers in your car up very loud, you can hear the sound gets distorted. The same happens to the signal coming from the sensor in your camera. If you try to amplify it too much, it gets distorted, and you’ll start to see odd colors and grain show up in your image. The only way to avoid this is physically make the sensor larger – full frame (or medium format, or even larger!) – to capture more light in the first place!
That leads me to my reasons for buying, and experiences with the 750 vs the 7100. I shoot in a lot of dark places. Much of the time it’s stationary stuff like stars and trees, so fps has never been a priority for me. however, I’ve shot more than my share of speakers at conferences, kids running around at VBS etc. in dimly lit or dark rooms to say that the 6.5fps of those two cameras has pretty much always been adequate. plus, for me, the benefits of the full frame in the D750 MORE than make up for the lower framerate. Is your situation the same? I don’t know, but that should give you something to think about.
the tl;dr version of all this:
Crop sensors are good for fast frame rates and gaining some extra reach from your lenses
Full frame are better in low light.
Imo, the D750 is just about the perfect balance of camera for just about every situation. It’s not the best at one or the other. Dedicated sports pros might want the D500, D4s, etc. Dedicated landscape pros might be better served by the D810. But, for me who shoots a little of everything, but likes landscapes and shoot often in low light, the D750 is hard to beat.You might check this article out, it probably will answer other questions you might have. https://photographylife.com/reviews/nikon-d750/7
Matthew StevensParticipantfor #1 and 2, I pretty much do what James describes.
As far as cloud backups, I don’t use any sort of live cloud backup system like photostream on an iphone, or like the new Lightroom CC that was just announced today. That’s largely because of a) slow internet, and b) cost. It’s just not practical for me with my relatively limited internet bandwidth to be constantly uploading and downloading images to Adobe cloud etc., no matter how convenient it may be. I also like to know that I have total control over my image files, and that my only copy isn’t floating around somewhere on adobe’s servers, where I have to pay a subscription to access them. Plus, if I’m going to edit my pics, I’m going to do it on my color calibrated monitor at home – not on my ipad. While it would be neat to be able to view them on the ipad wherever I was, for my workflow I just don’t see the real benefit of Adobe cloud.
The other problem is cost. Adobe CC Photo includes 20GB of cloud storage. My photos folder is 320GB… if I wanted to upload all those to the AC, I would have to either give up Photoshop and switch to the Lightroom-only CC plan, which includes a TB of storage, or else pony up $20/month for Lightroom Classic CC + 1TB. There currently are no cloud photo services that offer unlimited storage for raw files, although there are several (Smugmug, amazon photo, for example) that are unlimited for jpg/tif/etc. It’s just not worth it for me to pay extra for something like Adobe cloud, that won’t work well on my internet, and locks my originals away somewhere that I have to pay to access.
That said, if you’re mainly concerned about straightforward backups of your originals (rather than live-photosyncing), one option is Google Drive. I have a 1TB account (not just for photos), which allows me to store a copy of my entire originals collection offsite. Dropbox, Box.com etc would work similarly. I run backup software every night that updates the Drive copies with any changes I’ve made to my local originals. Add to this the regular hard drive backups I do, and I feel pretty secure about not losing any of my work.
And I don’t separate my edited files, they stay in the folder with all the other raw images from that shoot. Instead, I use the lightroom catalog to organize my favorite images into collections, which are the ones I’ll normally take the time to edit.
Matthew StevensParticipantI just upgraded from a D7100 to a D750. Both are great cameras, the main reason for the upgrade was that I do a lot of night time photography, astro etc., as well as some indoor stuff in dark places (auditoriums). The D7100 does a good job under these circumstances with a fast lens (just ask James, he’s seen what it can do), but the low light performance in the D750 is AMAZING. Large sensor=larger light receptors=more light gathering power. It’s also much less noisy at high ISO (you can get reasonable photos at 12800, which is impossibly high for a dx sensor).
If you were to go with the D750, I’d do a kit like this one https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1082604-REG/nikon_d750_dslr_camera_with.html with the 24-120mm f/4. It’s a great lense, and good combo for general shooting.
If you were to go DX, you can’t really go wrong with the D7100/7200. The sensors are outstanding, and even in low light they do a good job. FX is going to be better just because of physics, but I’ve shot tons of astro and event stuff in dark situations with my 7100 over the last 4 years, and it holds it’s own.
Incidentally I have a d7100 and a couple of lenses sitting on my desk looking for a buyer… 🙂
But, if you’ve got the cash – go with the D750, you won’t regret it at all.
Matthew StevensParticipantWell, the same thing applies to GIMP. I do a lot with gimp, there’s some stuff it does better that PS. You still wind up losing image quality on every save because of how jpeg compression works, so just work with tif until you’re finished making your edits, then export as jpeg. That way you get max quality + small files. 16 vs. 8 bit has less to do with it than does lossy jpeg compression.
Matthew StevensParticipantBasically, if I am going to edit a photo further outside of Lightroom, I will export a tiff. Otherwise, it goes out as jpeg. Like, say I needed to do some touchup work with the healing brush or whatever in Photoshop, I’ll save a tiff out of Lightroom and then work on it in Photoshop. The ONLY reason for this is that tiffs are lossless…even if they are compressed, information does not get discarded from the image when you save your edits.
On the other hand, a jpeg is LOSSY. Every time you save, the jpeg engine in the software you are using analyzes the image according to how the human eye perceives color, contrast, etc., and then discards some information from the file in order to save space. If you edit, then save a jpeg a whole bunch of times, each time it’s discarding information, and each time you save, your image quality goes down.
That said, if you are finished making edits to the file, either in LR or PS, just export as a jpeg. It will look the same to your eye, and the file with be orders of magnitude smaller (as you figured out…)
So, my standard workflow is either:
lightroom -> jpeg (if I’m not making edits outside of lightroom), or
lightroom -> tiff -> jpeg (if I am making outside edits in gimp or PS)You pretty much covered all that already @buddingphotographer…Just wanted to add my 2 cents.
Matthew StevensParticipantI use an fstop lotus http://shop.fstopgear.com/us/product/mountain/lotus.html
Kind of expensive, but totally worth it. I’ve hiked with it, flown with it, loaded it down with more weight than it’s supposed to hold… It’s water resistant, you can get a rain cover for it, modular straps for tripod/camping gear, you can change the ICU inserts for different lens/camera combinations, or take the ICU out completely and just use it as a backpack. It also has rear-panel access to the camera compartment, which means if you dump it off on the muddy ground to get your camera out, your back stays nice and dry when you put it back on.
It’s got an internal frame, and a good waist strap which, if you are going to be hiking with anything more than 15-20lbs of camera gear I would highly recommend. The difference between the Fstop and the Lowepro Fastpack I upgraded from is that the Fstop seems to have actually been made with carrying decent amount of gear while hiking in mind – with the Fastpack, with the 30-35lbs of gear I usually haul when I’m on a trip (4 lenses, 1 camera, 13″ laptop, batteries, change of clothes, snacks, water, etc.) my shoulders would tend to get *really* sore while hiking. Not so with the Lotus. The only downside is the price…but if you think you’ll be mostly using it for travel and hiking, you really can’t do better.
Matthew StevensParticipantAs long as the XMP files are in the same directory as the raw images (not in subdirectories, but just mixed in there with the raw files), and have the same filename as their respective raw images, Lightroom should read them automatically.
If not, assuming the images have been added to Lightroom, go to the metadata menu and click “read metadata from file.”
Matthew StevensParticipantThe metadata in a DNG file is actually still XMP data (it can be stored in other formats too, such as exif). The difference is that it just gets recorded right into the DNG file itself rather than in a sidecar file. So, with DNG its the same story as the .xmp sidecar files, there’s still no edit history, collections info, flags, etc. That stuff only exists in the catalog – so back it up!
I have changed my opinion over time about converting everything to DNG. I used to do it to every photo, and sort of wish I hadn’t now.
I wrote up a little thing about why here if you’re interested.
Matthew StevensParticipantfor future information, the whole import-as-a-catalog thing is how I manage using Lightroom on my desktop and laptop. Whenever I am on a trip or whatever using my laptop (which has limited storage space), I’ll just start up a temporary catalog on there and do all my imports, backup, tag/sort my photos, etc while on the road. Then, when I get back home I’ll export everything from the laptop “as a catalog”, including the negatives and previews (see screenshot), and then import that into my master catalog on the desktop. This keeps all my edits and metadata/flagging/collections intact. Makes the whole process pretty easy, and a lot less prone to losing things…which I have done using other methods 🙂
Matthew StevensParticipantLR 6/CC zips them up by default now, which definitely helps with storage space! I also have it set up so the backups save to my backup drive(s), rather than to the default location (never understood why you would ever want your backups to end up in the same place as your original catalog)
Matthew StevensParticipantJust FYI the metadata that gets written to the XMP files do not include the full history of edits that were made on the photo.I was always under the impression that XMP was sort of a backup of all my edits, flags, etc. that would stay with the image no matter where it went, but it turns out this is not the case. It is true that your edits get stored – whatever the most recent state of the image is in Lightroom, including snapshots. – but the edit history does not get recorded. Neither do your flags, ratings, or collections info.
I still write changes to XMP, but now I know I can’t rely on that as an alternative to a full backup (or multiple copies of a full backup!) of my actual catalog.
Matthew StevensParticipantCheck here for exact times in your local area. It’s going to be a late night for us here on the east coast… 🙂
Matthew StevensParticipantGreat! Nice shot, btw.
Matthew
-
AuthorPosts

